The age of remote-control warfare isn't coming--it's here, and
not even the Air Force, which made it happen, is entirely
prepared. Here, a firsthand look at the struggle to train
thousands of drone pilots virtually overnight.
Fit to Fight:
Armed with precision-guided bombs
and missiles, the Reaper MQ-9 is the deadliest war drone
yet. Here, it sits on the flight line at Creech Air Force
Base in Nevada. Lance
Cheung/U.S. Air Force Photo
Without traffic, it takes Captain Adam Brockshus about 45
minutes to drive from his four-bedroom suburban home outside Las
Vegas to Creech Air Force Base in Indian Springs, Nevada. His
commute follows Highway 95 northwest through a stretch of the
Mojave freckled with Joshua trees and flanked by arid mountain
ranges. He trains pilots for combat in Iraq and Afghanistan, yet
this desolate drive may be the most harrowing part of his job.
Tall, blond and new-daddy doughy, Brockshus spends the rest of
his day in a windowless room full of office chairs and computer
monitors, teaching 20-somethings how to fly war drones 7,500
miles away. Although his is, for all intents, a desk job, it may
be one of the most critical posts in today’s Air Force. The
number of unmanned aircraft missions has more than tripled in
the past two years, and the Air Force can’t train people fast
enough to keep up with the demand. Brockshus’s responsibility is
to churn out new drone pilots, and churn them out fast.
Until a few years ago, most of what he knew of unmanned
aerial vehicles (UAVs) came from whatever he might have read in
magazines like this one. Operating killer drones wasn’t even an
option in 2001, when he was accepted to Air Force flight school
after graduating from South Dakota State University, because
weaponized UAVs didn’t exist. Not that he necessarily would have
gone that route. While some of his classmates were bent on
flying F-16s, the competitiveness of such a career wasn’t for
him. “For a fighter it makes absolute sense, but I’ve never been
that aggressive type,” says Brockshus, whose serene brow could
fit right alongside the granite faces of Mount Rushmore in his
native South Dakota. “I felt more at home with the heavies.” And
so it was that he wound up flying KC-135 refueling tankers, like
his father.
As his first tanker tour in Mildenhall, England, wound down
in 2007, he and his wife were discussing having a second child,
and the prospect of another tour didn’t appeal to either of
them. One of the problems with flying KC-135s is that the
Eisenhower-era fleet is prone to breakdowns, and Brockshus was
often diverted to any number of places to wait out repairs. So
when the Air Force offered to reassign him to Nevada, Brockshus
thought it sounded good.
In the short time since he arrived at Creech, Brockshus, now
30, has become one of the Air Force’s more experienced pilots of
one of its most unexpectedly valuable weapons, the MQ-1
Predator. Along with its bigger and deadlier brother, the MQ-9
Reaper, these armed and remotely controlled spy planes have
generated what Air Force Chief of Staff General Norton Schwartz
calls an “insatiable” demand among ground commanders in Iraq and
Afghanistan, not to mention special operations in Pakistan. It’s
easy to see why. At this moment, dozens of armed drones circle
miles above insurgents, watching everything in real time, with a
resolution sharp enough to read a license plate. Every month
they stream 18,000 hours of live video to commanders,
intelligence officers and ground troops; they track vehicles,
scan convoy routes for explosives, and fire missiles. Unlike the
F-16, a Predator can remain above a target for 24 hours, while
pilots like Brockshus spell each other in shifts, perhaps
watching the sun rise over Afghanistan on their video monitors
before driving home in the dark. “They give you a capability
that you never had,” says retired Air Force Colonel Tom Ehrhard,
a leading UAV expert. “And when you couple it with a lethal
system, guess what? It’s magic.”
In the end, what lured Brockshus out of the heavies was not
the “magic” of bombing targets each day from afar, but being
able to tuck his kids in at night. It’s a lifestyle the Air
Force hopes will attract new recruits to the job.
 |
Step 1: Call in an order.
Ground units in Iraq or Afghanistan file hundreds of
requests a day for air support from the constantly
airborne 31 Predators and three Reapers among the Air
Force’s fleet. Missions include tracking vehicles,
scanning roads for bombs, and providing cover for
troops. |
 |
Step 2: Wait for
Approval.
With demand outpacing supply, the Joint Forces Air
Component commander can approve just a fraction of the
requests. Once cleared, a pilot crew in the U.S. diverts
an airborne UAV [above, a Reaper] to the designated
hotspot. |
 |
Step 3: Track the
Data.
The Predator and Reaper drones stream up to 18,000 hours
of live video a month to ground troops and pilot crews
back home. The Predator can stay aloft for up to 24
hours, the Reaper 16. |
 |
Step 4: Find the
target.
The pilot communicates with an airman on the ground
through a secure radio signal transmitted through a
satellite link to determine targets. |
 |
Step 5: Fire.
Once a target is marked, the ground commander clears the
pilot crew for “kinetic engagement.” The pilot fires the
missile, while the sensor operator aims the drone’s
laser, constantly adjusting the beam to remain on
target.
Click here for a an annotated video of a live
Hellfire missile strike. |
In
this video, exclusive to PopSci.com, Captain Adam
Brockshus narrates a Hellfire missile strike on a group of
insurgents in Afghanistan. As a Predator instructor pilot,
Brockshus was called into the Ground Control Station to oversee
a former student who was taking his first shot in combat. The
insurgents gave themselves away when, apparently, they
accidentally detonated an IED they were trying to set up. The
pilot's instructions were to target the second man in the group.
The spindly remote-control plane that began as an
experimental aerial intelligence gopher for the Army during
the Balkan wars in the mid-1990s has morphed into a
full-fledged weapons system. But with it, the Air Force’s
unmanned program has become a victim of its own success.
After 9/11, it rushed the armed Predator into service
without so much as an instruction manual, and now it’s
struggling to figure out how to integrate the UAVs into an
increased workload. The Air Force’s current strategy of
yanking combat pilots from their cockpits to retrain them to
fly drones is depleting other squadrons, leaving the service
short of pilots to fly manned planes. It’s also a slow and
costly way to staff up. The education required for a pilot
to fly unmanned aircraft is comparable to that of earning a
master’s degree, and even the best-trained pilots struggle
with the learning curve. More than a third of the 200
Predators delivered to date have crashed catastrophically,
due to both aircraft malfunction and human error. One pilot
executed a hard left at high speed—perfectly doable in a
manned combat craft but not a maneuver the Predator, powered
by a snowmobile engine, can handle; it flipped over and
spiraled out of control. Several other operators
accidentally switched off the engine mid-flight. One
inadvertently erased the onboard RAM, and with it any hope
of controlling the aircraft. “That this was even possible to
do during a flight is notable in itself and suggests the
relatively ad hoc software development process occurring for
these systems,” wrote human-error specialist Kevin Williams
of the Federal Aviation Administration in a 2004 analysis of
UAV crashes. As Colonel John Montgomery put it to a group of
reporters at Creech last March, “We’re on the ragged edge.”
After being chastised by its own audit agency last
December for failing to establish a dedicated career track
for UAV pilots, the Air Force is now jamming pilots through
its primary operator school at Creech. The immediate goal is
to create a cadre of 1,100 drone pilots, up from the
existing ranks of about 400, and to boost unmanned combat
patrols 47 percent within the next two years. To accomplish
this, 100 airmen will go straight from the traditional
12-month undergraduate pilot training to Creech this year,
where they’ll learn to operate the Predator and immediately
begin flying combat operations.
The Air Force’s long-term solution, however, hinges on a
radical new program to train non-aviators for the job and
establish two pilot pipelines—one for manned flight and one
for unmanned flight. Trimmed of the intense undergraduate
training that pilots go through, the “beta” school takes
nine months instead of 16. This month, eight captains with
four to six years of experience in the service, and with
little to no previous aviator skills, will graduate from the
abbreviated track after logging just 20 hours of manned
flight, versus the conventional 200. Nobody knows yet
whether this hurry-up strategy will serve as the foundation
for a more efficient, more affordable fighting force or
undermine the Air Force’s own ambitious vision of ruling the
skies with combat ’bots.
The Air Force doesn’t have time to debate it. The final
20 F-22 Raptors, the so-called 21st-century fighter jet,
arrive this year, while more than twice that number of
Predators and Reapers will also enter service. In May,
Secretary of Defense Robert Gates underscored this seismic
shift in procurement priorities at a hearing about the 2010
budget, telling senators who were recalcitrant over the end
of the $150-million F-22 that the solution to future threats
“is not something that has a pilot in it.” Already the Air
Force will train more drone pilots than fighter and bomber
pilots combined this year. Meanwhile, Congress is coughing
up an additional $2 billion for Intelligence, Surveillance
and Reconnaissance, the agency that encompasses UAVs.
Although the Air Force has been invested in the spy trade
for more than 50 years, the ability to conduct unmanned and
armed reconnaissance is a whole new business, and one it
aims to own.
THE NEW FACE OF AIR POWER
Zipped into a flight suit and dressed for battle,
Brockshus stands over a trainee slouched in a tan naugahyde
chair, schooling him in the art of modern warfare. The
setting looks like a simulator, but somewhere out there, a
real drone is hovering over the Nevada desert, waiting for
the trainee’s instructions. “So let’s see if you can hook
around to get a better view,” Brockshus says. Calm though
not quite laid-back, he’s mastered the kind of clear,
deliberate radio cadence that gives ground commanders the
confidence to call in an air strike with “friendlies”
nearby.
Brockshus and two enlisted instructors deliver today’s
lesson as part of Predator initial qualification training,
designed to teach airmen how to operate the plane and deploy
its weapons, laser-guided Hellfire antitank missiles.
They’re in a tight room within one of Creech’s many newly
erected buildings. It serves as the ground-control station
for the “schoolhouse.” In a real combat situation, a ground
crew would launch a Predator or Reaper in Iraq, say, and
then hand off the plane via satellite link to a crew in the
U.S. at either Creech, one of several Air National Guard
bases or at a special-operations unit in New Mexico.
Ideally, there would be 10 crews for every 24-hour air
combat patrol to cover all the shifts, maintenance,
vacations and such, but now they’re running thin at seven.
So thin, in fact, that there are no transfers out of Creech,
and some pilots have been stuck on the desert base, wryly
known as the Oasis, for five or six years (three is
typical). To get the equivalent coverage from an F-16 unit,
however, the Air Force would need to deploy three times as
many people, and none of them would have the luxury of
sleeping in their own bed.
Brockshus’s charge, Captain Timothy Kile, is a
33-year-old former Air National Guard helicopter pilot from
Arizona. He sits in front of an array of monitors, two
yellowish Reagan-era keyboards and a trackball that’s
mounted in place. One of the two primary monitors shows the
video feed from the plane’s cameras overlaid with a head-up
display of the horizon, the plane’s altitude and other
vitals. Another screen displays a graphic of the plane
overlaying satellite maps of the landscape. There’s a
joystick too, but it’s mostly for takeoffs, landings and
chasing targets. Typically, drones follow a preprogrammed
flight path. To change directions, Kile draws a shape
onscreen like you might in Photoshop and sits back as the
automated plane heels to the line. To his right sits Staff
Sergeant William Keltner, who after 11 years in the service
found himself reassigned from graphic designer to sensor
operator. Although the pilot is responsible for the plane,
the sensor operator’s job—to track targets and provide the
best picture to the commanders and intelligence officers
scrutinizing his feed—is more demanding. Keltner has an
identical setup, except that his joystick controls the
Predator’s $1-million sensor ball, known as the unblinking
eye for its suite of sensors: electro-optical, infrared,
video, and laser-target marker.
The big, blocky chairs seem like they
should swivel, but of course they
don’t. This is not a place one idly
spins in circles or puts feet up on
the desk. Today’s lesson is target
tracking, and after a low-key
classroom session and mission brief
this morning, things are heating up.
Brockshus, along with sensor operator
Jonathan Oakley, 24, and mission
intelligence coordinator Michael
Furger, 22, who are both instructors,
challenge Kile and Keltner to find a
particular white SUV. Information and
acronyms fly from everywhere. The
rookie Predator crew is, in military
parlance, “drinking from the fire
hose”: Keltner: “OK, we’ve got eyes on.”
Furger: “Copy that.”
Brockshus: “When it gets to a vehicle
chase, I want a crew that’s nonstop
chatter. Stuff like, there’s a
butterfly-shaped IR signature on the
hood, so when it gets packed in a
Baghdad traffic jam—and cars are
everywhere—you’ll be able to spot it.”
…
Brockshus: “It’s easy to get
complacent. You have to be thinking
ahead of where he’s going to be
scanning.”
Kile: “I wasn’t paying attention.”
Oakley: “And you didn’t mark PID
[positive identification].”
Kile: “No, I did not.”
Oakley: “So what would you do to get
back on target?”
Kile: “I’d zoom out and use my PID
features.”
…
Furger: “We’re cleared off that
target. Stand by.”
Brockshus: “Funnel navigation. Always
be working big to small, big to
small.”
Furger: “Any recent vehicle activity
there?”
Kile: “Let me switch to IR now. I
don’t see anything.”
Furger: “Any of those parking spots
been used recently?”
Kile: “I’m not sure where you’re going
with this. . .”
Stumped, Kile and Keltner glance at
each other and then squint back at the
video feed, which is full of blank
parking spaces. Oakley reveals the
magic: With infrared, darker means
cooler, so a darker space could be an
indication that a vehicle was there,
shading the pavement from the heat of
the sun.
The sensor operator is doing more
actual work as the pilot sits and
watches. And in the event the pilot
pulls the trigger, launching a missile
from the wing, it’s the sensor
operator who actually tags the target
with the laser designator for the
missile. It can be a nerve-racking 30
seconds trying to keep a moving target
in the crosshairs. Oh, and there can
be a two-second delay before the data
is decompressed and the sensor ball
moves. Oakley says that even though he
grew up playing Microsoft Flight
Control and has more than 1,200 hours
in the Predator, he still finds
operating UAVs challenging. It’s
definitely no videogame.
WHO'S FLYING THIS THING, ANYWAY?
So what does it take, exactly, to
produce a UAV ace? To start with, the
same skills required to master any
other aircraft, according to experts
like Colonel Eric Mathewson, who
switched from flying F-15s to UAVs 10
years ago after a back injury forced
him out of the cockpit. If that’s
true, though, will sending pilots
directly to Predator grad school
without the full foundation of
aviation training rob them of
“airmanship,” that immeasurable suite
of skills that includes sound
judgment, proficiency under duress,
and a sixth sense called situational
awareness—knowing where your plane is
in the three-dimensional battle space?
Sitting in Nevada, says Kile, “You
don’t get that seat-of-the pants
feeling.”
On the other hand, should that
matter? With drones, all the
information you need to fly is right
there in front of you, numerically and
visually—the same information a
cockpit pilot would use to fly at
night. And you don’t have the added
stress of worrying about dying. Either
way, the beta training is designed to
find out. “It’s called ‘beta test’
because it’s a test, a guess,” says
Mathewson. “It’ll be modified.”
If the standard undergraduate pilot
training proves expendable, it’s not
hard to imagine a distinct set of
characteristics that recruiters might
look for in the UAV pilots of
tomorrow. Maybe a little less
barnstormer and a little more geek.
Predator pilots don’t need the killer
instinct so much as the ability to
switch from boredom to rapid-fire
project management when a target is
getting away. “One of the things
that’s very difficult to wrap your
arms around is that we have So. Much.
Information,” said a Predator operator
and former fighter pilot, Captain
Patrick, who would give only his rank
and first name because he’s involved
in combat operations. “Look at all
these monitors. It’s learning how to
filter and find and utilize that
information correctly. You’ve got to
be able to multitask in a fighter, and
you’ve got to do that even more so
here. It’s harder.”
PATTERNS OF LIF
Brockshus doesn’t particularly love
the commute to Creech every day. But
when he was still flying combat
operations, it served as a buffer
between the stress of work and his
home life. “Sometimes I’ll be sitting
there having a soda on the couch and
think, Wow, an hour ago, I was just at
war,” he says.
A month after he began flying
combat UAVs, he and his crew were
watching a trigger house, which gives
insurgents a vantage over a roadway to
detonate an IED as a vehicle passes.
Brockshus had spotted two people
stringing wires from the house to the
road the night before, but that wasn’t
enough to go on. This night, however,
the figures appeared to pull back a
dark spot on the road and
crouch—plugging in wires. Seeing that
feed, the ground unit gave him
clearance to fire, and he launched a
missile. He saw it reach one of the
men. “It landed right at his feet,
and—” Brockshus pauses. “He was gone.”
His wife was in bed when he arrived
home at 2 a.m. after filling out all
the reports. She gave him a groggy
hug, said she was proud he took his
first shot, and fell back to sleep.
He’ll never forget the date. It was
his daughter’s second birthday, and he
had cake with her before heading off
to work.
|