Wednesday, Nov. 9, 2011, the
Zenit-2SB rocket with the Phobos-Ground probe blasts off from its launch
pad at the Cosmodrome Baikonur, Kazakhstan. Some of the recent failures
of Russian spacecraft may have been caused by hostile interference,
Roscosmos chief Vladimir Popovkin said. Popovkin made the comment when
asked about the failure of the unmanned Phobos-Ground probe, which was
to explore one of the Mars twin moons, Phobos, but became stranded while
orbiting Earth after its Nov. 9 launch.
Technicians work on the Phobos-Ground
probe at Baikonur, Kazakhstan.
MOSCOW (AP) — A Russian spacecraft designed to burnish the nation's faded
space glory in a mission to one of Mars' moons has turned into one of the
heaviest, most toxic pieces of space junk ever.
It will come crashing down to Earth in just a few days.
The Russian space agency Roscosmos' latest forecast has the unmanned Phobos-Ground
probe falling out of Earth's orbit Sunday or Monday, with the median time
placing it over the Indian Ocean just north of Madagascar. It said the precise
time and place of its uncontrolled plunge can only be determined later, and
unless someone actually spots fiery streaks in the sky, no one may ever know
where any surviving pieces end up.
Space experts agree it's unlikely to pose big risks.
At 13.2 metric tons (14.6 tons), the Phobos-Ground is one of the heaviest
spacecraft ever to plummet to Earth, considerably larger than the two defunct
satellites that fell to Earth last fall and landed in the water. It's
cylindrical and about the size of a van.
Roscosmos predicted that only between 20 and 30 fragments of the Phobos probe
with a total weight of up to 200 kilograms (440 pounds) will survive the
re-entry and plummet to Earth.
It's the third satellite to crash out of the sky in under five months: An old
NASA 6-ton atmospheric research satellite came tumbling down in September, and
a 3-ton German science satellite followed suit in October. But both were well
past their prime.
Russia's Phobos-Ground probe is still a mere babe. It was launched in
November, and a glitch left it stranded in orbit around Earth instead of bound
for Mars to collect soil samples.
"What's different about this re-entry is that it's not a re-entry of an old,
inert satellite that just was expected for years. It's something that is
coming down because of an accident ... for me, that puts it in a different
category," said Jonathan McDowell of the Harvard-Smithsonian Center for
Astrophysics in Cambridge, Mass.
Another striking difference is the 11 metric tons (12 tons) of highly toxic
rocket fuel aboard Phobos-Ground, accounting for the bulk of its weight for
the long journey to the Martian moon of Phobos. This makes it potentially the
most toxic spacecraft to fall ever.
Roscosmos insists all the fuel will burn in the atmosphere and pose no danger,
and some experts in Russia and the West share that forecast.
And if it's any consolation, both of the two previous uncontrolled satellites
harmlessly showered fragments over water.
"The fuel indeed poses lethal danger in case of close contact, but I haven't
heard of a single case of any civilians poisoned by rocket fuel from all the
derelict satellites and failed rockets throughout the space era," said Igor
Lissov, an independent Moscow-based space observer. "The objective reality is
that it burns on re-entry. There is no reason to panic."
Some experts theorized, however, that part of the fuel might have frozen in
the cold of space and could survive the fiery descent, posing a strong threat
if it spills over populated areas. Such fears prompted the United States to
shoot down its USA-193 spy satellite with a Navy missile in 2008.
Some botched Russian rocket launches in the past have showered fragments over
populated areas in Siberia and neighboring Kazakhstan.
In the latest such mishap, fragments of a Russian satellite that failed to
enter a designated orbit after its launch last month came down around
Novosibirsk, the third-largest Russian city with a population of about 1.5
million, damaging some houses but hurting no one. The fragments of the
Meridian satellite, however, fell from a lower altitude at a far slower speed
than the Phobos-Ground debris will have on re-entry.
Engineers from the Moscow-based company NPO Lavochkin, which built the Mars
probe, said in an article giving a detailed description of the design that its
fuel tanks are made of aluminum alloy. That means they should melt early on
re-entry, backing up official assurances that the fuel would burn up on its
McDowell said the probability is low that a large lump of toxic stuff will
He noted that some of the probe's equipment is dense and could survive
re-entry, but added the odds are that any surviving pieces will wind up in the
"All the best rules in the world" put in place to prevent uncontrolled
satellites from crashing down do little if any good in the event of a launch
failure, McDowell said. "This is always going to be the risk that something
breaks, and you end up with a situation like this. You can minimize it, but
you can't prevent it entirely."
The $170-million Phobos-Ground mission was Russia's most expensive and the
most ambitious space endeavor since Soviet times. The spacecraft was intended
to land on the crater-dented, potato-shaped Martian moon, collect soil samples
and fly them back to Earth, giving scientists precious materials that could
shed more light on the genesis of the solar system.
The probe was successfully launched Nov. 9 and entered a preliminary orbit
where its engines were supposed to fire to set it on its path to Mars. They
never did, and attempts to fix the glitch by Russian and European Space Agency
Russia's space chief has acknowledged the Phobos-Ground mission was
ill-prepared and risks of its failure were high, but said that Roscosmos had
to give it the go-ahead so as not to miss the limited Earth-to-Mars launch
Phobos-Ground marked Russia's first planned foray beyond Earth's orbit since a
botched 1996 robotic mission to Mars. That probe, designed by the same
Lavochkin company, crashed shortly after launch due to an engine failure. The
firm also built two other Phobos-bound probes that failed in 1988.
The crash of Mars-96 generated strong international fears because of some 200
grams of plutonium onboard. The craft eventually showered its fragments over
the Chile-Bolivia border in the Andes Mountains, and the pieces were never
Russian officials continue to insist the craft plunged into the Pacific, their
way of deflecting criticism for not warning the inhabitants of the impact area
and for failing to search for plutonium and other debris.
Fears of radiation also were sparked by the fall of a nuclear-powered Soviet
spy satellite that crashed over northwestern Canada in January 1978. The
Soviets claimed the craft completely burned on re-entry, but a massive
recovery effort by Canadian authorities recovered a dozen fragments, most of
which were radioactive.
The Phobos-Ground contains a tiny quantity of the radioactive metal Cobalt-57
in one of its instruments, but Roscosmos said it poses no threat of
AP Aero space Writer Marcia Dunn contributed from Cape Canaveral, Fla.